Sal's Authentic New York Pizza - York St Menu (Updated 2026)

Sal's Authentic New York Pizza at York St presents a menu centered on classic New York-style pizza alongside a selection of specialty sides and combo deals. The pizza offerings focus primarily on 14-inch pies, featuring options such as Cheese, Brooklyn (with pepperoni, sausage, and meatball), Chicken and Tomatoes, Manhattan (pepperoni and mushroom), and customizable half-and-half pizzas. Specialty sides include garlic knots available in different quantities, breaded mozzarella sticks served with marinara sauce, and buffalo chicken wings. Pricing for sides ranges from approximately $4.50 to $19, while pizzas are priced from $30 to $40 per 14-inch pie.

Several pizza deals combine multiple 14-inch pizzas with sides and beverages, catering to group orders. These packages, such as The TriState and The Tribeca Trio, offer combinations of pepperoni, cheese, and specialty pizzas, with prices between $45 and $90. The menu structure separates pizzas, specialty sides, and pizza deal categories clearly, supporting straightforward selection based on individual and group needs. Overall, the pricing remains within a medium range suitable for casual dining or shared meals.

The menu emphasizes classic New York-style pizzas, with notable options including the Signature Cheese & Pepperoni Slices and specialty pizzas like the Brooklyn and Manhattan varieties. Pricing indicates a broad range, from affordable individual slices and dipping sauces starting around A$2–3, to premium 14-inch specialty pizzas priced between A$30 and A$40. Appetizers such as Garlic Knots, Mozzarella Sticks, and Buffalo Chicken Wings complement the pizza offerings. Desserts like Zeppoles provide sweet options at a moderate price point. The presence of build-your-own and half-and-half pizzas suggests customization is available for varied appetites or group orders.*