Sal's Authentic New York Pizza - York St

Top categories (Specialty Sides / Drinks / Sauces / Pizzas 14'inch / Slice Specials)
Most orders: $1–20

Sal's Authentic New York Pizza - York St is a casual pizza restaurant offering traditional New York-style pizza with a focus on authentic flavors and quality ingredients. The establishment provides a variety of service options including dine-in, takeaway, and delivery, making it convenient for quick bites, solo dining, or group meals. The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming, suitable for families and individuals, with seating available both indoors and outdoors. The venue is accessible via a wheelchair-accessible entrance and offers parking nearby, complementing its location.

Operating hours extend from late morning through to midnight on select days, accommodating lunch, dinner, and late-night dining needs. Payment options include credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, enhancing customer convenience. The menu features a range of pizzas, sides, desserts, and beverages, catering to varied tastes with options ideal for casual dining or catering events.

With counter service designed for efficiency, Sal’s maintains a straightforward approach suited to both dine-in customers and those seeking a quick takeaway. The price range is reflective of casual dining expectations, providing quality pizza options without premium pricing. For a detailed view of the full menu offerings and to explore specific dishes, users are encouraged to visit the dedicated menu page.

Delivery
Takeaway
Dine-in

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Wheelchair-accessible entrance

Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments

Murrays World

02/03/2026

We had an issue with uber delivering our order just this once, and the amazing team at sals replaced our order at our convenience. Awesome customer service and a big thanks to Alex who was amazing on the day !!!! Amazing food as always

Meera Patel

25/02/2026

Rocky and Evelin are incredible. We stopped by around 10:45pm to get a late night pizza slice before heading back to the hotel. They were ram packed and busy with pre orders and they kindly took our order as we were celebrating a birthday and went over and above to make our pizza special! We ordered the medium cup pepperoni, but they realised they ran out so they apologized by offering us complimentary garlic knots on the side and to celebrate the birthday they gave us a chocolate mousse. This is a great hole in the wall pizza place. The crust is crisp and the sauce is perfect. What great people!

Emma Bruce

04/01/2026

Absolutely delicious pizza. Quick and clean and worth a wee detour on the light rail. Open late and perfect for a stop on your way home. Staff were lovely too.

Anita

04/01/2026

Fear not when you see the pizzas getting reheated. My goodness, they tasted as if they were fresh out of the oven after a quick revival. I think it is best eaten at the joint, not takeaway. The pepperoni is a must. This was honestly the best NY style pizza I’ve ever eaten in Australia. Cheese sticks are also freshly fried and delicious. Can’t wait to come back again to try the other pizzas!

Shawn Buttling

23/12/2025

I’m from New York living in Sydney for over 30 years. I’ve been waiting years for a New York Slice of pizza and now Sals is the go to.. it taste just like from NY. Sals proves the pizza is better in New York is not because of the water! It’s because of his craft!

Benno W. Putuhena

23/12/2025

Indeed the taste is authentic Friendly owner The place is small and cozy Should come here and try all the menu

Dud M

19/12/2025

Great pizza, a slice of chicken pie. Returned and pizza quality is not NY style - didn’t stand by itself this time - not crispy enough base. Still good though, service was average and non committal, seems they don’t want to be here.

Antony Royer

14/12/2025

Visited Sal’s during a trip to the city—the “New York” sign definitely caught my eye. We ordered the Queens Meal (18in Pizza, half pepperoni, half cheese), which came out piping hot with a drink and garlic knots (a fun twist on garlic bread). We also grabbed a beer on the side. The food is decent overall. There’s seating both inside and outside, and parking is street‑only. Since it’s a busy area, public transport is the better option. The shop is directly opposite Wynyard Bus Stop Stand G and only a short walk from Wynyard Station’s York Street entrance. If you’re nearby and craving a quick bite, it’s worth stopping in.

Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *